Skip to content 
Quick Answer:
In most cases, calling a locksmith is the smarter choice. While DIY lock repairs may seem cheaper upfront, mistakes can lead to costly damages, making professional locksmith services the better long-term investment.
If the repair is simple, such as lubricating a sticky lock, DIY might be a good option. However, for complex issues like broken keys, misaligned deadbolts, or smart lock malfunctions, a locksmith can fix the problem quickly and correctly.
Trying to fix a lock yourself can be tempting, but not all lock issues are easy to handle without the right tools or experience. In this guide, we’ll break down the real costs of DIY vs. hiring a locksmith, when DIY makes sense, and when calling a professional is the smarter financial decision.
Need expert locksmith services? Locksmith Oakville provides affordable, fast, and professional lock repairs, replacements, and installations for homes and businesses.
DIY Lock Repair vs. Hiring a Locksmith: Cost Breakdown
How Much Does DIY Lock Repair Cost?
If you attempt to fix a lock yourself, here’s what you might need to spend:
Lock lubricant (graphite or WD-40) costs between $5 and $10. Replacement lock parts, such as springs, pins, or cylinders, range from $10 to $40. A lock repair kit, which includes tools for disassembly and reassembly, costs between $20 and $50. If the repair fails and you need to drill and replace the lock, you could spend anywhere from $50 to $200.
The total estimated DIY cost ranges from $10 to $200 or more, depending on the repair needed. However, if something goes wrong, you may end up damaging the lock or door, requiring a full lock replacement, which costs even more.
A professional locksmith charges based on the type of repair or replacement needed. Basic lock repairs, such as realignment, lubrication, or tightening loose parts, typically cost between $50 and $100. Lock rekeying, which involves changing the internal pins to work with a new key, costs between $75 and $150. A full lock replacement, if the lock is too damaged to repair, costs between $100 and $250. Smart lock repair or reprogramming ranges from $100 to $300. If you’re locked out and need emergency service, expect to pay between $75 and $150.
The total estimated locksmith cost ranges from $50 to $300. Locksmith Oakville offers upfront pricing with no hidden fees, ensuring you know what to expect before the work begins.
If the issue is minor, you may be able to fix it yourself without risk.
For sticky or hard-to-turn locks, try lubricating the lock with graphite powder or WD-40. If the door handle or lockset is loose, tighten the screws with a screwdriver. A misaligned strike plate can often be adjusted so the deadbolt fits properly.
If these small fixes don’t work, it’s best to call a professional before causing more damage.
While minor lock issues are safe to handle yourself, more complex problems require a professional locksmith.
If a key breaks inside the lock, extracting it incorrectly can damage the internal mechanism, but a locksmith has the right tools to remove it safely. A jammed or non-turning lock cylinder typically requires disassembly and specialized tools. If you need to rekey a lock, a locksmith can change the internal pins without replacing the entire lock. Smart lock malfunctions should also be handled by a professional to avoid being locked out or disabling key access. If your home or business was recently broken into, replacing or upgrading your locks is the best way to ensure security.
If you’re unsure whether you need a locksmith, Locksmith Oakville provides free consultations to help you decide.
Why Hiring a Locksmith Can Save You Money in the Long Run
Avoid Costly Mistakes
DIY repairs can accidentally damage the lock or door, leading to higher costs. A locksmith ensures the job is done correctly the first time.
Get the Right Lock for Your Needs
If a lock needs replacing, a locksmith can recommend the best security upgrade for your home or business, rather than wasting money on the wrong lock.
Save Time and Hassle
A locksmith can fix most lock problems in under an hour, whereas DIY repairs often involve trial and error, research, and multiple trips to the hardware store.
Preventing Future Lock Issues
To avoid future lock repairs or replacements, follow these simple maintenance tips:
Lubricate your locks every six to twelve months to prevent sticking. Check door alignment—if your door is sagging or misaligned, the lock will wear down faster. Replace worn-out keys before they break inside the lock. Upgrade to a high-security lock if you live in a high-risk area.
For expert advice on lock maintenance, Locksmith Oakville can inspect your locks and recommend the best solutions.
Final Verdict: Should You Fix a Lock Yourself or Call a Locksmith?
DIY is a good option for small fixes, such as lubrication or tightening screws. However, calling a locksmith is the better choice for broken locks, jammed cylinders, rekeying, or smart lock issues.
In the long run, hiring a locksmith is often the cheaper and safer choice, as it prevents costly mistakes and ensures the job is done right.
For fast, reliable lock repair, Locksmith Oakville offers affordable, professional locksmith services with upfront pricing and no hidden fees. Call now or visit Locksmith Oakville to book an appointment.
